Reusing disposable water bottles vs. buying dedicated bottles

My reason to not buy bottled water is that it often takes several times as much water to make the bottle as the water it contains.

But when you buy a bottle of water, for whatever reason, you should at least re-use the bottle a few times to get the most out of the water used to make the bottle.

You should always think whether your re-use of a bottle is safe and suitable for your situation, but when staying in build up area or in an area which is well supplied with places to buy/refill your bottles, re-using water bottles for a few times is safe and brings down the waste.

It is of course better to use a bottle which will not add to the waste pile, and when you are done with whatever plastic bottle it should end up in recycling.

posted over 6 years ago

CC BY-SA 4.0

Willeke‭

161 reputation 0 36 16 0

TL;DR

Reusable water bottles have a higher failure rate than other containers, but they are reliable enough for short trips, and bringing 2 or 3 in case 1 fails should be reliable enough even on medium-length trips.

Citation

I go through a lot of bottles of water, I would estimate thousands of them per year, as I am supporting a family of 6 on a daily basis and some other people intermittently and everyone in the family drinks a lot of bottled water with some of us trying to reuse them when we remember to do so. Therefor, the high rate of failures I note below is partially due to the volume of bottles used being much higher than your normal person or family. Also, we are not careful with them, so they take a beating.

First, don't buy the super cheap reusable plastic bottles

Beware of the super cheap, plastic, reusable bottles, as some of them are junk and should be expected to break on the first or second outing if not handled with extreme care. I am not even considering the ones that you can get for a buck or two on the discount shelf.

Disposable water bottle failure

I have had disposable water bottles fail for me many times and in various ways. Leaks due to improper sealing at the cap, leaks in any random place due to tears or tiny holes, catastrophic tears that immediately empty the container, etc.. There are a variety of ways they can go bad.

I would say disposable bottle failure rate per bottle for non-reused bottles is way less than 1%. But I do reuse a lot of them, sometimes for a week or two. When heavily reusing, I would estimate that the failure rate is greater than 1%, but I don't keep track and cannot specify how much greater. Probably less than 10% though.

Reusable bottle failure

We have also used a lot of permanent, reusable water bottles, and we have had problems with those as well. Some of the problems are the same or similar: leaks due to bad seals at the cap, catastrophic destruction from bottles tearing or crushing, and tiny holes in some of the flexible plastic containers.

That said, I would estimate that the failure rate for the permanent bottles was lower than the failure rate for the disposable bottles. Disposable bottles are not made to be quite as tough, so they fail more often.

My conclusions

I'm not sure what the upper limit is on my reuse of disposable bottles, as I don't keep track, but more often than not I replace them because I was in a situation where I could just grab up another new one, not because the old one broke. That is anecdotal evidence that they can usually be reused a bunch of times without failing.

If you are going out for an ultra-light trip for a weekend, reusing disposable water bottles should be fine. I have done this, and I have reused the same water bottle for a week or two. If you are going out for more than 1 day, I would highly recommend that you bring at least 2 of them, even if you plan to be able to refill them often, just to be safe in case one does malfunction. Though malfunctions are not common, they happen at least enough that I would not risk being out with only 1.

If you do not need ultra-light, I would recommend a permanent steel bottle. I have had malfunctions even with them, but it is far less often. I have had leaks at the seals even on metal bottles, and I have dented and punctured them. However, dents and punctures in steel bottles is usually due to some form of damage that would have obliterated some lesser bottle. Even when dented, they still work great as long as they are not leaking; I had a steel bottle I used for a while even with a big dent in it. Be careful though of points in dented steel bottles being sharp enough to cut through your pack, or even cut you, if the ends of the dent are bent sharply enough. My preference is the ones you can also cook in, not the drinking-only ones that have paints on them and might be lined with other materials.

Another benefit of bringing 2 disposable water bottles instead of 1 reusable one on a trip is that, even though each disposable is more likely to fail on its own, I would say that having multiple disposable bottles all fail on 1 trip is probably less likely than having the 1 reusable bottle fail. So 2 or 3 disposables is likely more reliable than 1 reusable.

Summary

The failure rate is low enough when reusing disposable water bottles that you can do it for days, often even weeks. But the failure rate is high enough that it would be unwise to trust your hydration to only 1 of them. If the trip is longer than a day, bring at least 2, and if the trip is for weeks, bring even more than 2.

posted over 6 years ago

CC BY-SA 4.0

Loduwijk‭

301 reputation 19 45 36 0

I usually buy one single-use bottle and keep it until losing it. One bottle I had for around a year, it was a PET bottle. Another one I've now used for almost a year and replaced it just because it was a bit unstable and - might have been my imagination - got smelly faster. Or maybe I just wanted a change.

What I remember about an even older bottle is that I couldn't remove the dents any more after a while of use, so you would be looking for a stable bottle. I've not had any plastic bottle break, but that might just have been luck. I use these bottles almost daily, but do not maltreat them otherwise.

I heard, but don't know much about particles of plastic leaking into the water, but don't see how this is different for new bottles compared to used ones.

About cleaning: I half fill them, shake them strongly, and repeat that two to three times. With this, they don't develop any smell/taste for two days at least (but depending on the bottle). The only thing that needs occasional special cleaning is the cap.

posted over 6 years ago

CC BY-SA 4.0

questionasker‭

11 reputation 0 1 1 0

I used to complement my 3 litre hydration bladder with one or two 1.5 litre plastic bottles in dry climates, where carrying 3 litre of water may not be enough.

However, when I first hiked on multi-day trips in areas where water filtration is essential, I realised that the Steripen does not enter the relatively small opening of those bottles. Therefore, I bought a proper bottle with a larger opening, at a non-profit store in a U.S. National Park.

posted over 6 years ago

CC BY-SA 4.0

gerrit‭

746 reputation 136 94 113 0

A reasonable compromise is any pop bottle -- one designed for carbonated beverages. They are several times as strong as the water bottles. I've never managed to break one.

I have a polyethylene conventional water bottle that fits a pocket in my pack. I also carry a 2 liter pop bottles for times when I will be away from water for the bulk of the day. (Ridge walks, extended passes.) I've done whole trips with the 2 liter staying empty.

The PE bottle has the convenience of the pop-up top. The pop bottle has a screw cap.

Some water bottles have a popup cap. If you search you may find one that matches the standard pop bottle thread.

One of the downsides of a pop bottle: The risk of loosing the cap. If you can't find a popup cap, you can make a leash for it using thin high strength braided nylon line. Secure one end to the cap by drilling two holes in the cap, running the line in one, out the other. Tie it, and put a drop of shoo-goo or silicon seal on it. Tie the other end to the neck of the bottle, leaving about 3-4 inches of slack.

For winter travel, put a pair of socks over the bottle. I used to run all-day orienteering contests in winter. I made up 2 liters of coffee with lots of milk and sugar, put a pair of old work socks over the bottle, and had at least warm coffee at the end of the day.

Sports drink bottles will also work. They aren't quite as tough as the bottles for carbonated beveragges, but they have a wider mouth which makes them easier to fill and clean.

posted over 6 years ago

CC BY-SA 4.0

Sherwood Botsford‭

1032 reputation 9 247 106 0

Not a true outdoors hiking scenario but thought I could share my experience with reusing single use bottles.

I drink lots of double concentrate squash, I prepare 3x 1 litre bottle of diluted squash before work each day, throw them in a should bag or back pack and carry them 3 miles to work and back like this.

They bottles themselves will last me for a very long time, but the caps wear out after about a month of being opened and closed ~20 times a day each.

I have never had any other source of leaks other than loose caps.

posted over 6 years ago

CC BY-SA 4.0

J.Doe‭

11 reputation 0 1 1 0

I reuse "single-use" plastic bottles many, many times. Generally, they do not break.

The big advantage of many outdoor-use plastic bottles, however, is that the lid remains tethered to the bottle. So, if there's some risk in losing a lid – such as when kayaking or backpacking – I'll use one of those.

Now that I think of it, I should experiment with ways of making lid tethers...

posted over 6 years ago

CC BY-SA 4.0

Martin F‭

204 reputation 11 34 22 0

So far, I've always used PET bottles, and they never failed during a hike. Replaced them after each tour for hygienical reasons, but that's it.

The primary reason I prefer them over my Nalgenes is the weight. For the weight of one 1L Nalgene, I could fit 7,5L into 5 single-use ice tea PET bottles (they were square-shaped, easier to stow, and thin walled). I crumpled them to save space, compressed half-empty bottles, and none of those showed any sign of possible leakage across a 4 week Iceland hike. Similar with thicker multi-use bottles on 2-week trips, no problems.

Generally, PET bottles often have "ribs" to handle overpressure - those can expand, squeezing a bottle or having carbonated drinks in them won't cause leaks or break the bottle. There are "hydraulic press" videos on youtube that demonstrate how much pressure those bottles can withstand. In contrast, having carbonated water in a Nalgene created quite a mess the last time I tried, because the bottle itself is rigid, and any overpressure will try to get out of the only movable part, meaning the lid.

posted over 6 years ago

CC BY-SA 4.0

Dynat‭

11 reputation 0 4 1 0

This answer may not be the answer you're looking for, nor related to the outdoors, but
Do not reuse PET bottles

PET is a very porous type of plastic and it may become more porous with each use. The problem with these pores is that you cannot clean them fully. Soda, saliva and whatever will get stuck in these pores and they are a haven for bacteria. Don't think that the dishwasher helps. Heating up some types of plastic, especially a plastic like PET, is generally a bad idea.

I'm making it sound a lot worse than it is. A lot of people reuse PET bottles with no issue and there are governmental recommendations about cleaning PET bottles online (a quick googling brings up a page from the Centre for Food Safety in Hong Kong). However, a water bottle made of a more permanent plastic is safer to use and probably not all that expensive, so I don't see a point in reusing PET bottles.

posted over 6 years ago

CC BY-SA 4.0

Kapten-N‭

1 reputation 0 1 0 0

The problem with using the cheap bottles is that if they break, you can be in serious trouble. A quick price check says that 32 oz nalgenes go for around 10 bucks and 2 liter hydration bladders for around the same, so are you really saving that much money for the extra trouble?

I have seen Nalgene 32 oz bottles (which is pretty much the standard for outdoor groups) last 20+ years, while the reusable ones just get crushed after a while.

Companies will also put their logos on Nalgenes and give them away and so they can be free or bought second hand. I have also found a few out in the woods.

The reusable bottles do weigh less, but you have to compare that benefit to how would it be if they break. On short trails, or ones with plenty of places to resupply, they would make more sense. On long hikes in the desert, where you can be most of a day between water sources, not so much.

Quite simply, water is one of the most essential things you are carrying, don't skimp on the cost (especially when it's under $25).

posted over 6 years ago

CC BY-SA 4.0

Charlie Brumbaugh‭

4269 reputation 382 566 574 43

On the bottom of the plastic bottle should be a number.

#1, PET bottles leach antimony (a metallic element, Sb, atomic number 51) into the water.

Over time and with sunlight exposure, more antimony leaches out of the plastic and it is harmful, and PET water bottles are recommended only for 1-time use.

Other plastics can also be harmful.

Probably some kind of stainless steel water bottle is the safest.

See this for a comparison of the different types of plastics

posted over 6 years ago

CC BY-SA 4.0

System‭

2019 reputation 180 537 246 0

During my years in school my mum always reused ordinary water bottles to give me and my brother. Never had any issues with them breaking or something similar. But after some time they'd get somewhat dirty on the inside, which made me stop use them and instead buy a designated water bottle, which was way easier to clean on the inside.

posted over 6 years ago

CC BY-SA 4.0

Suimon‭

1 reputation 0 1 0 0