Painful leather hiking boots - persevere or give up?

In my experience, if shoes aren't comfortable when I first put them on in the shop and walk about in them for a few minutes, they are probably never going to be comfortable (or making them comfortable is going to be more trouble than they are worth) so there's no point buying them. I refuse to put up with sore feet because shoes don't fit right - the onus should be on the manufacturers to make comfortable footwear.

That said, sometimes a specially made Shoe Last can be put into shoes when you take them off to keep them in shape or stretch them into a more comfortable shape, but from what you describe, these boots were made with stitching ridges and/or stiffeners in inappropriate places that are causing you the problems you describe, so you can't even trim them down without destroying the shoe.

As an option of last resort and insufficient funds, before I decided to implement my strict personal "If it isn't right in the shop, don't buy it" policy, I have added 0.5mm to 1.0mm thick cardboard (heavy plastic sheeting might do as well) cut to shape to the problematic areas, either inside my socks or between my socks and the shoes. In your case, a piece covering the heel and a piece over the top of the foot should help. Make sure the card you use is fairly flexible, or it will cause its own problems. If necessary, thicker card can be shaved down around the edges with a sharp blade to prevent them from being painful. When (not if) the cardboard pieces wear out, you might consider sending them to the manufacturer with a description of how you use them and ask them to consider what their shoes would have had to be doing to your feet for the card to get into this condition.

posted over 10 years ago

CC BY-SA 3.0

Monty Wild‭

1 reputation 0 1 0 0

I'm not saying that you should continue with the break in, but I can say that I bought a pair of Red Wing Boots some month ago, and the break in

• took a lot longer than what you describe (at least 60 hours of walking I would say)
• included one "session" as described by berry120 - making them completely wet, and wearing them until they were dry

The whole thing was, to be honest, a really horrible experience. At one point, I had really bad blisters; I took a two-week vacation from the break-in, which is what I highly recommend to you before continuing. Let your feet heal completely, then do the wet-to-dry session.

Also, always wear two pair of socks, a pair of very thin on the inside, with very dense material, and a pair of thicker socks on the outside.

posted over 10 years ago

CC BY-SA 3.0

Manuel Kießling‭

11 reputation 0 1 1 0

Any advice is greatly appreciated; I can't really afford new boots, especially since this experience has taught me I probably shouldn't buy cheap ones, but I really do need some as I keep missing hiking and walking activities.

I wouldn't characterize those boots as cheap. 150 pounds is $250, which is a lot of money.

If expensive, heavy boots aren't working for you, why not just do your hiking and walking in comfortable, cheap, lightweight running shoes? As you get into heavier and heavier footwear, it gets more and more difficult to stay comfortable and avoid blisters.

The other thing is that you may simply have bought the wrong size. Your feet expand when you hike all day, so often you want to buy shoes or boots for hiking that are much larger than you'd otherwise buy. In US sizes, people often buy a full size larger.

posted over 10 years ago

CC BY-SA 3.0

Ben Crowell‭

751 reputation 42 185 81 0

• First I recommend "moleskin" this is a padding with a adhesive back that you can cut to size and stick to your foot for the problem areas. It is used for blisters, but if you have a problem spot you can let it get worn down first instead of you foot.

• Wear two pairs of socks, but two different types. The first pair being a thin "dress sock" type or something like nylon. The second pair use a thicker sock like your wool (or polypropylene - very nice but expensive).

The type of shoe in the picture looks problematic as well, It looks like it comes up right under the ankle joint and probably rubs really bad there. I usually buy boots that go higher up to avoid rubbing around that area - however since you already have this pair, it might help taking a spoon and rubbing the inside of the shoe where it usually rubs on your feet, assuming this is not initially a size problem.

posted over 10 years ago

CC BY-SA 3.0

Mateo‭

11 reputation 0 1 1 0

I have extremely wide feet which do not fit all shoes comfortably. I discovered a product at a shoe repair store, smelling something like nail polish remover, with which one wets the inside of the boot. The wet boot is then fitted onto the feet and allowed to dry. It shortens the time required to adjust the leather and works remarkably well.

posted over 10 years ago

CC BY-SA 3.0

Lori‭

11 reputation 0 1 1 0

With shoes, if I find a pair I like - I wear them for a good 10-15 minutes in the store. Standing up, sitting down, walking, climbing stairs (if possible) - all to get a sense of how they feel doing these different things. If they're painful in the store - they'll be painful everywhere else.

There's a thing about feet that isn't necessarily true of any other body part - size isn't the only factor. I can be assured that a 34-34 pant will fit, but a 12 shoe might not. In some brands I need a 12W, other brands assume I have higher ankles (the shoe rubs the underside of my ankle bone), some brands assume I have no arch while others assume I've got more arch than I actually have.

You may be able to salvage your relationship with these shoes if you can find a good cobbler. It sounds old fashioned, but I've had work done to shoes to fix minor annoyances - and I think a good cobbler might be able to find a solution to your problems without too much fuss (or money).

posted over 10 years ago

CC BY-SA 3.0

Michael‭

1 reputation 0 1 0 0

Modern boots really don't need a period of breaking in like they used to many years ago. They should be reasonably comfortable as soon as you try them on when buying them. To be honest, it sounds like the boots just don't fit your feet properly. It doesn't matter how good or bad the boots are quality-wise or how much they cost: if they don't fit your feet, then they will always give you trouble. I'm not talking about the size of the boots. Boots are made on what are called "lasts" and these are different shapes even for the same size. Your best bet is to visit a good shop where the staff will measure your feet properly and help you choose a pair of boots which fit you properly.

posted over 10 years ago

CC BY-SA 3.0

Paul Lydon‭

201 reputation 2 64 20 0

I know this post is probs a bit late for the original poster. However, I grew up thinking that walking boots had to be worn in and were supposed to be initially uncomfortable for the wearer. Having watched my father hardening his feet in surgical spirits before and after wearing what looked to be hard leathery walking boots, I wasn't looking forward to ever wearing a pair.

Still, I got to my early thirties, and having decided I liked the outdoors, decided to buy a pair. With a limited budget, I sat in Blacks trying on the cheapest own brand shoes (having never spent more than £40 on a pair of shoes). I tried on a pair of Peter Storm shoes, and yes, they were hard and unforgiving, but I thought that was what they were supposed to feel like at first.

I was about to buy them, when out of curiosity I thought I'd see what the fuss was about with the more expensive shoes. I tried a pair of Berghaus on at £80, well….what a difference! Like walking on a cloud of marshmallow pillows! I had to buy them, and that was a decade ago.

I have NEVER had a blister in those shoes, I've walked through peat bogs, up mountains, through snow (with one pair of socks), and been as warm, dry and toasty as if I'd been walking on my own living room carpet. The thing I learnt was that, with shoes, the cheapest option is usually a false economy. You don't need the most expensive option, but try and compare, because you may have to buy many cheap pairs before you find one that suits, and by then, you might as well have bought the better quality pair . I've since bought my poor Dad a pair of Berghaus Explorers, and he's very grateful :-)

posted about 10 years ago

CC BY-SA 3.0

Mieke Gibson‭

1 reputation 0 1 0 0

If it is consitently a particular area of the foot that is suffering then you could try a trick I was told of a number of years ago. I "suffer" from having very (or in the case of when I went to get a pair of climbing shoes: "stupidly") wide feet.

Anyway the trick is to tie knots in the laces at strategic points, this essentially allows you to pull the laces to different tensions along the foot. I knotted my boots just before it changes angle upwards to not put so much tension on the widest part but still allow the ankles to be tied up tighter. Works a treat and saved having to let the shop having a go re-forming the leather on a ski-boot workstation.

Ironically wear my Grubs far more often and find them more comfortable. Added benefit of being far more waterproof when out shooting and walking the dog.

posted over 10 years ago

CC BY-SA 3.0

sako243‭

1 reputation 0 1 0 0

Any advice is greatly appreciated; I can't really afford new boots

Well there goes my #1 piece of advice - I don't want to rub it in too much at all, but it just goes to show how important it is to make sure your boots will be comfortable before committing. At this point it sounds like they're just a poor fit, they shouldn't be causing that much pain after wearing for that long.

However, there are a few things I'd try:

• I've never needed to do it myself, but I've heard of others soak their boots in warm water, put them on, and walk in them until they're dry. This may help to mould them around your feet a bit better, but obviously if this is too painful to practically do then there's no use pushing it!

• It sounds from what you're saying as though they're perhaps a bit tight in certain areas - one thing you might want to try to give you a bit more space is removing the supplied innersole, and replacing it with a much thinner one. You'll probably lose some of the shock absorbing capabilities of the shoe through this, but if this results in the rubbing significantly decreasing, I'd say it's a worthwhile tradeoff.

• May sound stupid, but how tight are you tying the laces? They don't need to be that tight. I've seen people ridiculously over-tighten laces to the point of it causing pain, then never even considering that that may have been an issue.

• You say you've tried more than one type of sock, have you tried two thin pairs of socks? This may help with the rubbing a lot more than one thick pair.

In short, it sounds like the boots will unfortunately never be a great fit, but I wouldn't discard them just yet - there's still a few things you can try to see if they can become acceptable.

To add to the (good) comment below, it's also worth mentioning more expensive isn't necessarily better. One of my favourite pairs of hiking shoes cost £20 in the sale, lasted me years and were incredibly comfortable. if you try cheaper pairs, you may be pleasantly surprised!

posted over 10 years ago

CC BY-SA 3.0

berry120‭

626 reputation 52 134 77 0